For weeks, alternative news outlets like The Grayzone and The Intercept have cast major doubts on Israel's claim that the al-Shifa Hospital in northern Gaza sat atop a major Hamas command center. Now, even an ultimate establishment outlet -- the Washington Post -- has likewise found that Israel's claims about the hospital it besieged don't stand up to scrutiny.
Mistrust existed even before the Israeli Defense Forces first besieged the hospital before bombing a departing ambulance convoy, and then raiding the hospital in November. While those who reflexively back Israel at every turn may have been fooled, others rightly rolled their eyes as the Israeli government presented the world with a cartoon version of what was supposed to lie under the hospital, as if that was some kind of proof:
“Hey everyone, we made a bogus animation to justify our mass murder of doctors, nurses, patients, and those seeking shelter at Al Shifa hospital in Gaza. We are the most moral military in the world.” https://t.co/mrQqj3OiWT
— Remi Kanazi (@Remroum) October 27, 2023
After its Nov. 15 raid of the hospital, the IDF distributed videos and photographs to bolster Israel's claims about the hospital, however the Post notes:
...the evidence presented by the Israeli government falls short of showing that Hamas had been using the hospital as a command and control center, according to a Washington Post analysis of open-source visuals, satellite imagery and all of the publicly released IDF materials.
That raises critical questions, legal and humanitarian experts say, about whether the civilian harm caused by Israel’s military operations against the hospital — encircling, besieging and ultimately raiding the facility and the tunnel beneath it — were proportionate to the assessed threat. -- Washington Post
The Post's analysis refuted three cornerstone allegations that Israel had made. First, there is no compelling evidence of military use of the facility by Hamas. Second, contrary to pre-attack claims, the single tunnel under the hospital doesn't connect to five other buildings on the hospital campus that were supposed Hamas operational hubs. Finally, the Post found no proof that hospital wards had tunnel access.
After raiding the hospital, the IDF released footage alleging to have recovered a mere dozen AK-47 rifles and a handful of grenades.
They also shared images of a tunnel shaft which was in a single small building on the northeast corner of the hospital campus. The tunnel led to two small bathrooms and two empty rooms.
IDF spokesman Daniel Hagari claimed the mere presence of electrical wiring proved one of the chambers was an "operational room." However, the Post notes that the rooms are remarkably pristine. Besides lacking any military flavor, they show "no signs of recent habitation, including litter, food containers, clothing or other personal items."
Note that, in a separate instance, Hagari has proven himself a highly undependable tour-guide -- to the point of earning widespread ridicule. In a video shot at a children's hospital, he claimed that papers on the wall showed the names of terrorists charged with guarding hostages. Arabic speakers were quick to note that the words he pointed to were simply the days of the week.
Not a Borat Sketch! The IDF Spokesman points to a random calendar at the Rantisi hospital as "evidence" of a "hostage keepers' list" with "terrorists' names".
— Muhammad Shehada (@muhammadshehad2) November 13, 2023
But the ONLY thing on that "list" is literally the days of the week (Saturday-Friday).
No tunnels, no weapon stash...🧵 pic.twitter.com/5kgPHtKfrA
Last month, former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak threw CNN's Christiane Amanpour for a loop when he said it was the Israelis who built bunkers under al-Shifa Hospital:
Amanpour: "When you say [the bunker under al-Shifa] was built by Israeli engineers, did you misspeak?
— Mehdi Hasan (@mehdirhasan) November 21, 2023
Ehud Barak: "No, decades ago, we were running the place... we helped them to build these bunkers."
Amanpour: "Ok. That's sort of thrown me a little bit."pic.twitter.com/CTYfMij2V0
Another piece of supposed evidence of the hospital's military use is also less than compelling. Security camera footage shows militants leading two Israeli hostages through the hospital on Oct. 7 -- the day of the Hamas invasion of southern Israel. However, one of the hostages appears wounded and is being transported on a gurney, seemingly indicating the militants took the hostage to the hospital for treatment.
The IDF said it destroyed the few tunnels it found under al-Shifa and then left the hospital, seemingly confirming that the cartoon version of the Israeli government's claims was nowhere near the truth.
Beyond simple assurances from officials, the Biden White House has done nothing to bolster Israel's claims about al Shifa -- failing, for example, to produce any declassified intelligence of its own. Meanwhile, an anonymous "senior member of Congress" tells the Post that, though he was once confident in Israel's claims about al-Shifa, he now needs more than animations, dubious photo "evidence" and "trust us" assurances: “I think there has to be a new level of demonstration. They should have more proof at this point.”
Attention hawks: It's okay for you to change your mind about this war. You do not have to move one atom's width to the left.
— Scott Horton (@scotthortonshow) December 21, 2023
Follow @JeremyRHammond's lead. He's a Ron Paul libertarian. What Israel is doing is not right. The US should not be party to it. https://t.co/mPGiGlXMhC
"The targeting by a U.S. ally of a compound housing hundreds of sick and dying patients and thousands of displaced people has no precedent in recent decades," notes the Post.
The IDF siege of the hospital caused misery for thousands of Palestinians trapped in the medical facility and sheltering on its grounds. According to the United Nations, at least 40 Palestinians died while the hospital was besieged by the IDF -- among them four premature infants.
For weeks, alternative news outlets like The Grayzone and The Intercept have cast major doubts on Israel’s claim that the al-Shifa Hospital in northern Gaza sat atop a major Hamas command center. Now, even an ultimate establishment outlet — the Washington Post — has likewise found that Israel’s claims about the hospital it besieged don’t stand up to scrutiny.
Mistrust existed even before the Israeli Defense Forces first besieged the hospital before bombing a departing ambulance convoy, and then raiding the hospital in November. While those who reflexively back Israel at every turn may have been fooled, others rightly rolled their eyes as the Israeli government presented the world with a cartoon version of what was supposed to lie under the hospital, as if that was some kind of proof:
“Hey everyone, we made a bogus animation to justify our mass murder of doctors, nurses, patients, and those seeking shelter at Al Shifa hospital in Gaza. We are the most moral military in the world.” https://t.co/mrQqj3OiWT
— Remi Kanazi (@Remroum) October 27, 2023
After its Nov. 15 raid of the hospital, the IDF distributed videos and photographs to bolster Israel’s claims about the hospital, however the Post notes:
…the evidence presented by the Israeli government falls short of showing that Hamas had been using the hospital as a command and control center, according to a Washington Post analysis of open-source visuals, satellite imagery and all of the publicly released IDF materials.
That raises critical questions, legal and humanitarian experts say, about whether the civilian harm caused by Israel’s military operations against the hospital — encircling, besieging and ultimately raiding the facility and the tunnel beneath it — were proportionate to the assessed threat. — Washington Post
The Post’s analysis refuted three cornerstone allegations that Israel had made. First, there is no compelling evidence of military use of the facility by Hamas. Second, contrary to pre-attack claims, the single tunnel under the hospital doesn’t connect to five other buildings on the hospital campus that were supposed Hamas operational hubs. Finally, the Post found no proof that hospital wards had tunnel access.
After raiding the hospital, the IDF released footage alleging to have recovered a mere dozen AK-47 rifles and a handful of grenades.
[embedded content]
They also shared images of a tunnel shaft which was in a single small building on the northeast corner of the hospital campus. The tunnel led to two small bathrooms and two empty rooms.
[embedded content]
IDF spokesman Daniel Hagari claimed the mere presence of electrical wiring proved one of the chambers was an “operational room.” However, the Post notes that the rooms are remarkably pristine. Besides lacking any military flavor, they show “no signs of recent habitation, including litter, food containers, clothing or other personal items.”
Note that, in a separate instance, Hagari has proven himself a highly undependable tour-guide — to the point of earning widespread ridicule. In a video shot at a children’s hospital, he claimed that papers on the wall showed the names of terrorists charged with guarding hostages. Arabic speakers were quick to note that the words he pointed to were simply the days of the week.
Not a Borat Sketch! The IDF Spokesman points to a random calendar at the Rantisi hospital as “evidence” of a “hostage keepers’ list” with “terrorists’ names”.
But the ONLY thing on that “list” is literally the days of the week (Saturday-Friday).
No tunnels, no weapon stash…🧵 pic.twitter.com/5kgPHtKfrA
— Muhammad Shehada (@muhammadshehad2) November 13, 2023
Last month, former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak threw CNN’s Christiane Amanpour for a loop when he said it was the Israelis who built bunkers under al-Shifa Hospital:
Amanpour: “When you say [the bunker under al-Shifa] was built by Israeli engineers, did you misspeak?
Ehud Barak: “No, decades ago, we were running the place… we helped them to build these bunkers.”
Amanpour: “Ok. That’s sort of thrown me a little bit.”pic.twitter.com/CTYfMij2V0— Mehdi Hasan (@mehdirhasan) November 21, 2023
Another piece of supposed evidence of the hospital’s military use is also less than compelling. Security camera footage shows militants leading two Israeli hostages through the hospital on Oct. 7 — the day of the Hamas invasion of southern Israel. However, one of the hostages appears wounded and is being transported on a gurney, seemingly indicating the militants took the hostage to the hospital for treatment.
The IDF said it destroyed the few tunnels it found under al-Shifa and then left the hospital, seemingly confirming that the cartoon version of the Israeli government’s claims was nowhere near the truth.
Beyond simple assurances from officials, the Biden White House has done nothing to bolster Israel’s claims about al Shifa — failing, for example, to produce any declassified intelligence of its own. Meanwhile, an anonymous “senior member of Congress” tells the Post that, though he was once confident in Israel’s claims about al-Shifa, he now needs more than animations, dubious photo “evidence” and “trust us” assurances: “I think there has to be a new level of demonstration. They should have more proof at this point.”
Attention hawks: It’s okay for you to change your mind about this war. You do not have to move one atom’s width to the left.
Follow @JeremyRHammond‘s lead. He’s a Ron Paul libertarian. What Israel is doing is not right. The US should not be party to it. https://t.co/mPGiGlXMhC
— Scott Horton (@scotthortonshow) December 21, 2023
“The targeting by a U.S. ally of a compound housing hundreds of sick and dying patients and thousands of displaced people has no precedent in recent decades,” notes the Post.
The IDF siege of the hospital caused misery for thousands of Palestinians trapped in the medical facility and sheltering on its grounds. According to the United Nations, at least 40 Palestinians died while the hospital was besieged by the IDF — among them four premature infants.
Loading…
