<!–

–>

January 17, 2024

A doctrine used once in December 1868 to make sure that former Confederate President Jefferson Davis never held office again has been revived to justify removing former U.S. President Donald Trump’s name from the ballot of the Colorado Republican primary. The doctrine, called self-execution, allows the terms of the 14th Amendment to be applied without action by Congress.

‘); googletag.cmd.push(function () { googletag.display(‘div-gpt-ad-1609268089992-0’); }); document.write(”); googletag.cmd.push(function() { googletag.pubads().addEventListener(‘slotRenderEnded’, function(event) { if (event.slot.getSlotElementId() == “div-hre-Americanthinker—New-3028”) { googletag.display(“div-hre-Americanthinker—New-3028”); } }); }); }

Self-execution is inconsistent with the 14th Amendment’s text, which provides for enforcement by the U.S. Congress. If it were ever applied to cases beyond those of Davis and Trump (and, as this essay argues, it’s seriously doubtful it should apply to Trump), the results would be chaotic.

Trump has appealed on the grounds that the Colorado ruling violates his due process rights. U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral arguments on February 8.

Section 3

‘); googletag.cmd.push(function () { googletag.display(‘div-gpt-ad-1609270365559-0’); }); document.write(”); googletag.cmd.push(function() { googletag.pubads().addEventListener(‘slotRenderEnded’, function(event) { if (event.slot.getSlotElementId() == “div-hre-Americanthinker—New-3035”) { googletag.display(“div-hre-Americanthinker—New-3035”); } }); }); }

In December 1865, Alexander Stephens, the former Confederate vice president, showed up at the U.S. Congress with several other former Confederates and demanded to be seated. It had been only eight months since Confederate General Robert E. Lee had surrendered at Appomattox. Stephens’s grandstanding prompted Congress to add Section Three to the as-yet-unratified Fourteenth Amendment, the section used by the Colorado Supreme Court to challenge Trump’s ballot status.

Section Three provides that “No person shall” hold U.S. public office who previously took an oath of loyalty to the United States but then “engaged in insurrection or rebellion against the same.”

Jefferson Davis

In June 1867, Davis was charged with rebellion, treason, and insurrection at the federal courthouse in Richmond. Ironically, this was the same building that he had used as an office during the war. His case was highly anticipated. It would be the “trial of the century.”

From the government’s point of view, a lot could go wrong. Trying Davis before a jury that included newly freed blacks could provoke a backlash. Were they truly his peers? At the very least, Davis would get a platform to present his views.

Even if he were convicted, Davis could appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court. Four justices had been appointed by Lincoln, but five had been appointed by earlier pro-slavery presidents. The judges who would ultimately decide the case were Supreme court Chief Justice Salmon Chase and District Judge John Underwood. No one knew how either court might rule. The prosecutors yearned for a solution that would get Davis out of public life.